2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
Moderators: Buscemi, BarcaRulz, Geezer, W
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I'm in favour. Just for this year, because of The Avengers issue. Why?> Because less choice of films with 250m+ potential imbalances the game. I prefer to see more high-earning choices to leve the playing field.
I understand Chien's point about being able to accurately track the numbers, but since it's this one weekend, and we all know it's gonna open at around the 200m level, we all know it's going to be one of the first 5 picks of the season. So not a huge disadvantage.
I understand Chien's point about being able to accurately track the numbers, but since it's this one weekend, and we all know it's gonna open at around the 200m level, we all know it's going to be one of the first 5 picks of the season. So not a huge disadvantage.
- Shrykespeare
- Site Admin
- Posts: 14273
- Joined: September 12th, 2009, 11:38 pm
- Location: Glendale, AZ
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
Repeating this post so people don't have to go back to the last page to see what Six is talking about....
In order to settle this, let's take a poll RIGHT NOW.
Who is in favor of allowing previously-released films to be drafted?
Any previously-released film chosen would only take effect beginning the immediate Friday AFTER being drafted. Any previously-released film drafted on a Friday or later will not have its take counted until the following Friday.
Because of the speed of the draft, it's likely only Avengers would be drafted, as all other films will likely have petered out by then.
Let your voice be heard now.
I personally am in favor of it. I hate that Marvel made this necessary, but we have to adapt.
IN FAVOR: Shryke, Six, Walleye, Leestu
PROVISIONALLY IN FAVOR: Spectre, Chien, Jas
AGAINST:
In order to settle this, let's take a poll RIGHT NOW.
Who is in favor of allowing previously-released films to be drafted?
Any previously-released film chosen would only take effect beginning the immediate Friday AFTER being drafted. Any previously-released film drafted on a Friday or later will not have its take counted until the following Friday.
Because of the speed of the draft, it's likely only Avengers would be drafted, as all other films will likely have petered out by then.
Let your voice be heard now.
I personally am in favor of it. I hate that Marvel made this necessary, but we have to adapt.
IN FAVOR: Shryke, Six, Walleye, Leestu
PROVISIONALLY IN FAVOR: Spectre, Chien, Jas
AGAINST:
Happy 60th birthday Jet Li! (4/26/23)
- Walleye413
- Marv
- Posts: 1765
- Joined: November 17th, 2009, 1:17 am
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I'll vote in favor of it. And since I'll pick first you can wonder as to whether or not I'll actually be selecting it if approved!
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I should just resign now to avoid the embarrassment of losing like thisnumbersix wrote:As Dolphins never was released, I'm gonna drop it for Disobedience. Watch out Spectre!
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I'll vote in favor of allowing one-off exceptions to be made (upon a forum vote) but I don't want all previously released films to be drafted. I'm adamantly against making it a blanket rule for all released films.
I guarantee you that at the end of the draft, a bunch of stuff that came out 1-2 weeks prior will go off the board instead of TBDs or limited releases because they're an easily projectible $10M+. And the double digit rounds are the biggest part of the challenge and one of the coolest aspects of the draft. If we did this rule across the board, it would turn a portion of it into a math exercise.
For example. If I Feel Pretty follows the path of Trainwreck from Week 2 on (when it made $17.3M), it'll still have $25M left in the tank when we're drafting. That took me 2 seconds to project and I'll be able to tell if its legs match as of next weekend. If they don't, I can just put a scalar on it and recalculate. That's lame IMO.
I guarantee you that at the end of the draft, a bunch of stuff that came out 1-2 weeks prior will go off the board instead of TBDs or limited releases because they're an easily projectible $10M+. And the double digit rounds are the biggest part of the challenge and one of the coolest aspects of the draft. If we did this rule across the board, it would turn a portion of it into a math exercise.
For example. If I Feel Pretty follows the path of Trainwreck from Week 2 on (when it made $17.3M), it'll still have $25M left in the tank when we're drafting. That took me 2 seconds to project and I'll be able to tell if its legs match as of next weekend. If they don't, I can just put a scalar on it and recalculate. That's lame IMO.
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I like the idea. I vote in favour.
- transformers2
- Neo
- Posts: 7803
- Joined: October 23rd, 2009, 5:15 pm
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I'm going to vote in favor. Infinity War is too valuable of a commodity to exclude it from this year's game.
BRING BRENDAN FRASER BACK TO THE BIG SCREEN DAMN IT
Check out my blog http://maitlandsmadness.blogspot.com/
Movies,Music,Sports and More!
Check out my blog http://maitlandsmadness.blogspot.com/
Movies,Music,Sports and More!
- Chienfantome
- Captain Jack Sparrow
- Posts: 9984
- Joined: May 29th, 2010, 4:22 am
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I pretty much agree with Spectre on the subject matter. And I do agree with Six that adding it will make the year more competitive. So I'll agree with, as long as it's a one-off, and we don't decide to make it a rule that we can draft any film that already opened in April. We do it exceptionally for this one only, and not for all the films available from April.
Fluctuat nec mergitur
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
I'm in favor of it only for Avengers as well.
- Shrykespeare
- Site Admin
- Posts: 14273
- Joined: September 12th, 2009, 11:38 pm
- Location: Glendale, AZ
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
Well, it would seem we have at least a partial consensus.
It would seem that the most logical recourse, rather than making drafting previously released films a free-standing rule, that we make an exception this year in the case of Avengers only.
Films like Rampage, A Quiet Place, and I Feel Pretty, though they may have a few million left in their tanks, will not be eligible for selection, as it seems clear that by 5/4 they will have made will over 50% of their total gross.
Fair?
It would seem that the most logical recourse, rather than making drafting previously released films a free-standing rule, that we make an exception this year in the case of Avengers only.
Films like Rampage, A Quiet Place, and I Feel Pretty, though they may have a few million left in their tanks, will not be eligible for selection, as it seems clear that by 5/4 they will have made will over 50% of their total gross.
Fair?
Happy 60th birthday Jet Li! (4/26/23)
- Walleye413
- Marv
- Posts: 1765
- Joined: November 17th, 2009, 1:17 am
- transformers2
- Neo
- Posts: 7803
- Joined: October 23rd, 2009, 5:15 pm
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
Fine by me
BRING BRENDAN FRASER BACK TO THE BIG SCREEN DAMN IT
Check out my blog http://maitlandsmadness.blogspot.com/
Movies,Music,Sports and More!
Check out my blog http://maitlandsmadness.blogspot.com/
Movies,Music,Sports and More!
- Chienfantome
- Captain Jack Sparrow
- Posts: 9984
- Joined: May 29th, 2010, 4:22 am
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
It doesn't matter, but I'm against it.
Tenet: Criterion Edition. Now with more Backwards Man.
- Shrykespeare
- Site Admin
- Posts: 14273
- Joined: September 12th, 2009, 11:38 pm
- Location: Glendale, AZ
Re: 2017-18 Full Year Slates (Division A)
Penultimate weekend!!
STANDINGS (WEEK 51/52)
1. Spectre - $1,365,960,152 (5 films - Ferdinand, Black Panther, Samson, Rampage, Traffik; 10 finished)
2. Geezer - $1,317,540,948 (2 films - Peter Rabbit, Strangers: Prey at Night; 11 finished)
3. Chien - $1,290,241,052 (5 films - Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, Pacific Rim Uprising, Midnight Sun, Ready Player One, Lean on Pete; 11 finished)
4. Six - $1,269,124,586 (3 films - Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri, Finding Your Feet, Blockers; 12 finished)
5. aquamann - $1,010,291,021 (4 films - Sherlock Gnomes, TP's Acrimony, You Were Never Really Here, I Feel Pretty; 12 finished)
6. Walleye - $894,400,595 (6 films - Coco, The Greatest Showman, Maze Runner: The Death Cure, A Wrinkle in Time, I Can Only Imagine, Chappaquiddick; 10 finished)
7. W - $810,359,534 (4 films - Tomb Raider, Paul Apostle of Christ, God's Not Dead: A Light in Darkness, Borg/McEnroe, Super Trooper 2; 9 finished)
8. JohnErle - $790,092,194 (4 films - The Post, Love Simon, Isle of Dogs, A Quiet Place; 8 finished)
9. Shaan - $732,491,831 (1 film - The Shape of Water; 11 finished)
10. UDM - $721,203,696 (4 films - Call Me By Your Name, The Miracle Season, Truth or Dare, Beirut; 12 finished)
The following films would appear to be done:
Star Wars: The Last Jedi (Geezer, 1st round) = $620,181,382
Game Night (aquamann, 5th round) = $68,205,293
Annihilation (aquamann, 7th round) = $32,732,301
I Tonya (aquamann, WW) = $30,014,539
Hostiles (Walleye, 13th round) = $29,814,750
The Hurricane Heist (Chien, WW) = $6,110,016
4/27:
Avengers: Infinity War (Shaan, WW)
Animal Crackers (Shaan, WW)
Disobedience (Six, WW)
STANDINGS (WEEK 51/52)
1. Spectre - $1,365,960,152 (5 films - Ferdinand, Black Panther, Samson, Rampage, Traffik; 10 finished)
2. Geezer - $1,317,540,948 (2 films - Peter Rabbit, Strangers: Prey at Night; 11 finished)
3. Chien - $1,290,241,052 (5 films - Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, Pacific Rim Uprising, Midnight Sun, Ready Player One, Lean on Pete; 11 finished)
4. Six - $1,269,124,586 (3 films - Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri, Finding Your Feet, Blockers; 12 finished)
5. aquamann - $1,010,291,021 (4 films - Sherlock Gnomes, TP's Acrimony, You Were Never Really Here, I Feel Pretty; 12 finished)
6. Walleye - $894,400,595 (6 films - Coco, The Greatest Showman, Maze Runner: The Death Cure, A Wrinkle in Time, I Can Only Imagine, Chappaquiddick; 10 finished)
7. W - $810,359,534 (4 films - Tomb Raider, Paul Apostle of Christ, God's Not Dead: A Light in Darkness, Borg/McEnroe, Super Trooper 2; 9 finished)
8. JohnErle - $790,092,194 (4 films - The Post, Love Simon, Isle of Dogs, A Quiet Place; 8 finished)
9. Shaan - $732,491,831 (1 film - The Shape of Water; 11 finished)
10. UDM - $721,203,696 (4 films - Call Me By Your Name, The Miracle Season, Truth or Dare, Beirut; 12 finished)
The following films would appear to be done:
Star Wars: The Last Jedi (Geezer, 1st round) = $620,181,382
Game Night (aquamann, 5th round) = $68,205,293
Annihilation (aquamann, 7th round) = $32,732,301
I Tonya (aquamann, WW) = $30,014,539
Hostiles (Walleye, 13th round) = $29,814,750
The Hurricane Heist (Chien, WW) = $6,110,016
4/27:
Avengers: Infinity War (Shaan, WW)
Animal Crackers (Shaan, WW)
Disobedience (Six, WW)
Happy 60th birthday Jet Li! (4/26/23)