Choice

[Ron Burgundy]

Simple game, where you must choose one, and one only. I'll try post daily.

David Fincher vs Darren Aronofsky

[Shrykespeare]

Fincher. Every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

[numbersix]

Definitely Aronofsky. Even when he fails he's still interesting. I can't find excuses for the banality of Benjamin Button, and Social Network was totally over-rated.

This is a mean game. I like it.

[transformers2]

David Fincher. Both of them have only made 1 film that I disliked, but The Fountain is much worse than Panic Room.

[Buscemi]

Aronofsky. Fincher is basically an Oscar whore now while Aronofsky still makes the films he wants to make.

[BanksIsDaFuture]

Aronofsky. Only because The Game is extremely weak, and the trifecta of Requiem/The Wrestler/Black Swan is tough to beat.

[empire13]

Though I like almost everything Fincher does, I have to go with Aronofsky. His artistic/symbolic design is present in everything he does. Requiem is one of the most artistic and hard hitting films I've ever seen. And, Black Swan is incredible.

[Buscemi]

Also, Aronofsky knows there are more than two colors.

[silversurfer19]

Also, Aronofsky knows there are more than two colors.

What? Black, and very, very dark grey?

Tough choice, but for Black Swan and Requiem/ Seven and Fight Club, it's probably Aronofsky. Just.

[Buscemi]

I was thinking black and brown but black and grey is an acceptable answer.

[Geezer]

Fincher, because Fight Club is a top 10 film.

[BanksIsDaFuture]

Very close. So far, it's 4-3 in favor of Aronofsky...

[JohnErle]

Very close. So far, it's 4-3 in favor of Aronofsky...

Not any more!

Fincher by a mile. Zodiac, Se7en, and The Social Network are all better than anything Aronofsky's ever done. Only Black Swan comes close.

[Ron Burgundy]

Well I'm going to with Fincher as well. Really looking forward to Gone girl with Ben Affleck. Both d.a and d.f are great directors.

Well as it stands its 5 a piece.

Next up:

Quentin Tarantino vs Christopher Nolan

[Geezer]

NOOOOOOOOOO