ReelSociety Forums

So what say ye? We're getting a little close aren't we? I still think we should do both.

And how can people vote for 1a and then not vote 3a? How are you going to vote to replace a film and then not be able to replace them after January?

1. B
2. B
3. D
4. A
5. A

Well, here goes:

1: Iron Man 2
2: Toy Story 3
3: Harry Potter 7
4: Twilight 3
5: Shrek Forever After
6: Alice in Wonderland
7: Green Hornet
8: Yogi Bear
9: Dinner for Schmucks
10: Rapunzel
11: Sex and the City 2
12: Little Fockers
13: Expendables
14: Karate Kid
15: Inception

b. can NOT be replaced.

a. 15 movies

d. 02.01.2010; 1st of February

b. the sum of the box offices calculated until 02.27.2011, according to BOM (exactly like in 2009); in case of equality (the same chosen movies), the winner will be the one with the total specified closer to actual total of Top 10 movies of 2010.

c. both versions; let's give it a try...


sorry if my votes are too late. Either way, what are the official rules and when can i put together a slate?

I waited too much... for your votes...

After JUST 10 votes:

1. the movies:
a. can be replaced, if they are not already released;
b. can NOT be replaced.

4 for a, 6 for b

2. you can choose:
a. 15 movies
b. 10 movies

6 for a, 4 for b

3. sign up date until:
a. anytime in 2010, but (of course) you can't choose the movies already released
b. 01.01.2010; 1st of January
c. 01.14.2010; 14th of January
d. 02.01.2010; 1st of February
e. 03.01.2010; 1st of March

1 for a, 3 for c, 7 for d (J.I. voted c or d)

4. the algorithm for calculating the TOT$ for each participant:
a. depending of the rank specified by participant - percentage of total cume (until 02.27.2011) of the movie specified: 1 - 100%, 2 - 95%, 3 - 90% ...14 - 35% and 15 - 30%; please see the above example; in case of equality (the same chosen movies, in the same order), the winner will be the one with the total specified closer to actual total of Top 10 movies of 2010.
b. the sum of the box offices calculated until 02.27.2011, according to BOM (exactly like in 2009); in case of equality (the same chosen movies), the winner will be the one with the total specified closer to actual total of Top 10 movies of 2010.

2 for a, 8 for b

5. you want to be a player of the:
a. new version
b. the old version
c. both versions; let's give it a try...

2 for a, 3 for b, 5 for c

LET's NOT waste TIME anymore!

SO, what I propose to you, after seeing your votes is:

1. we'll play 2 versions!; everyone invited if you want to play just the old version, fine by me, just the new version - OK, both (let's give it a try) - PERFECT!
2.1. version No. 1 - will be the same like the last 2 years: 10 movies, un-replaceable, the winner will be the one with the greatest sum of the box offices calculated until 02.27.2011, according to BOM (exactly like in 2009 and 2008); in case of equality (the same chosen movies), the winner will be the one with the total specified (of the 10 movies) closer to actual total of Top 10 movies of 2010;
2.2 version No. 2 - 15 movies, which can be replaced, if they are not already released,; the winner will be the one with the greatest sum - depending of the rank specified by participant - percentage of total cume (until 02.27.2011) of the movie specified: 1 - 100%, 2 - 95%, 3 - 90% ...14 - 35% and 15 - 30%; please see the example on the 1st page; in case of equality (the same chosen movies, in the same order), the winner will be the one with the total specified closer to actual total of Top 10 movies of 2010.
3. sign up date for both versions will be until: MARCH 4th - friends know why

LET'S PLAY

May the BEST win!

Not even one courageous ?

Let me break the ice!

For version No. 1: the estimated total - 2.75B

1. Iron Man 2
2. Toy Story 3
3. Shrek Forever After
4. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
5. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
6. Inception
7. Tron Legacy
8. Little Fockers
9. Alice in Wonderland
10. Clash of the Titans

For version No. 2: the estimated total - 3.5B

1. Iron Man 2
2. Toy Story 3
3. Shrek Forever After
4. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
5. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
6. Inception
7. Tron Legacy
8. Little Fockers
9. Alice in Wonderland
10. Clash of the Titans
11. Sex and the City 2
12. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
13. Oobermind
14. Rapunzel
15. The A-Team

The 10 game:

1.Iron Man 2
2.Toy Story 3
3.Harry Potter and The Deadly Hallows Part 1
4.Shrek Forever After
5.Eclipse
6.Little Fockers
7.How To Train Your Dragon
8.Megamind (formerly Oobermind)
9.Inception
10.Grown Ups

Total: $2.675 billion

The 15 game:

1.Iron Man 2
2.Toy Story 3
3.Harry Potter and The Deadly Hallows Part 1
4.Shrek Forever After
5.Eclipse
6.Little Fockers
7.How To Train Your Dragon
8.Megamind
9.Inception
10.Grown Ups
11.The A-Team
12.Alice In Wonderland
13.Clash Of The Titans
14.Knight and Day
15.Tangled (formerly Rapunzel)

Total: $3.365 billion

The 10 Game:

1. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
2. Iron Man 2
3. Toy Story 3
4. Shrek Forever After
5. Twilight Saga: Eclipse
6. Inception
7. The Chronicles of Narnia: Voyage of the Dawn Treader
8. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
9. How to Train Your Dragon
10. Little Fockers


For the 15 game, the above 10 plus add:

11. Alice in Wonderland
12. Salt
13. Grown Ups
14. Tron Legacy
15. Clash of the Titans

Here are my slates. Until when can we change them?


1. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows 1
2. Iron Man 2
3. Toy Story 3
4. Chronicles of Narnia: Voyage of the Dawn Treader
5. Shrek Forever After
6. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
7. Alice In Wonderland
8. Twilight: Eclipse
9. Clash of the Titans
10. Salt


for top 15


11. Sex and the City
12. The Last Airbender
13. Sorcerer's Apprentice
14. Megamind
15. Tron: Legacy

Ok here they are;

for Top 10

1. Iron Man 2
2. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
3. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
4. Toy Story 3
5. Inception
6. Shrek Forever After
7. Chronicles of Narnia: Voyage of the Dawn Treader
8. Alice in Wonderland
9. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
10. How to Train Your Dragon

Total: 2.8 Billion


for Top 15

1. Iron Man 2
2. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
3. The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
4. Toy Story 3
5. Inception
6. Shrek Forever After
7. Chronicles of Narnia: Voyage of the Dawn Treader
8. Alice in Wonderland
9. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
10. How to Train Your Dragon
11. Little Fockers
12. The A-Team
13. Grown-Ups
14. Sex and the City 2
15. Salt

Total: 3.5 Billion

I find it sad that I dont see more than 1 movie in my top 15 that is an original idea. (Salt is just a female bourne to me)
1.Iron Man 2
2.Toy story 3
3.Shrek 4
4.Eclipse
5.Harry Potter 7 pt.1
6.Inception
7.Tron Legacy
8.Little Fockers
9.Clash of the Titans
10.Prince of Persia

Top 10 Total: 2.97 Billion

11.Ateam
12.Narnia 3
13.Last Airbender
14.Salt
15.Alice in Wonderland

Top 15 Total: 3.82 Billion

@undeadmonkey: for v2 (the one with 15 movies) you can replace any movie you want as long as it's not already released...
you'll be able also to move them (from rank 4 to rank 10 for example)...
if a movie is already released, its rank will be locked...

MARCH 4th is the lock date for v1 (the one with 10 movies) - after that they can't be replaced...

so HURRY UP!

The 10 Game:

1. Iron Man 2
2. Toy Story 3
3. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
4. Shrek Forever After
5. Twilight Saga: Eclipse
6. Inception
7. The Chronicles of Narnia: Voyage of the Dawn Treader
8. Tron Legacy
9. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
10. Alice In Wonderland


For the 15 game, the above 10 plus add:

11. Clash of the Titans
12. Little Fockers
13. How To Train Your Dragon
14. Yogi Bear 3D
15. Sex and The City 2

Just 7 players??? where are the others??!

MARCH 4th is the lock date for v1 (the one with 10 movies) - after that they can't be replaced...

So HURRY-HURRY UP !

for v2 (the one with 15 movies) you can replace any movie you want as long as it's not already released...

I presume you're including my picks above? Just remove the last 5 and those are my picks for the Top Ten Game